3.11BThe understanding of genetics
Biology only — not on the Combined Science specification
In the mid-19th century Gregor Mendel carried out breeding experiments on plants. One of his observations was that the inheritance of each characteristic is determined by 'units' that are passed on to descendants unchanged.
Why Mendel's discovery was not recognised until after his death is a question in its own right. He was working before chromosomes had been seen, so there was nothing physical to attach his 'units' to; his work was published in an obscure journal and read by few scientists; and his mathematical, ratio-based approach was unlike the biology of the time, so its significance was not obvious. Only when chromosomes were observed behaving the same way did his results suddenly explain something.
This scientific work by many scientists led to the gene theory being developed.
3.12–3.14, 3.16Genetic inheritance
- Gamete
- A sex cell — sperm or egg in animals, pollen or egg cell in plants — with a single set of chromosomes.
- Chromosome
- A structure in the nucleus made of a long DNA molecule, carrying many genes.
- Gene
- A small section of DNA coding for a particular protein.
- Allele
- A different form of the same gene.
- Dominant
- An allele that is always expressed, even if only one copy is present.
- Recessive
- An allele that is only expressed if two copies are present.
- Homozygous
- Having two alleles the same for that trait.
- Heterozygous
- Having two different alleles for that trait.
- Genotype
- The alleles an organism has.
- Phenotype
- The characteristics that are expressed.
Some characteristics are controlled by a single gene — fur colour in mice, and red-green colour blindness in humans. Each gene may have different forms called alleles. The alleles present, or genotype, operate at a molecular level to develop characteristics that can be expressed as a phenotype.
Most characteristics, though, are the result of multiple genes interacting rather than a single gene. That is worth remembering when a question asks whether a single-gene cross is the whole story: it is not, and saying so is often the last mark.
Worked example
In mice, brown fur (B) is dominant and white fur (b) is recessive. Two heterozygous brown mice (Bb) are crossed. Give the expected ratio of phenotypes.
- Draw a Punnett square with B and b along the top for one parent, and B and b down the side for the other.
- Fill the four boxes: BB, Bb, Bb, bb.
- Read the phenotypes: BB is brown, both Bb are brown, bb is white.
- Count: 3 brown to 1 white.
Answer: A 3 : 1 ratio of brown to white — which as a probability means each offspring has a 3 in 4, or 75%, chance of being brown.
Express the outcome however the question asks, using direct proportion and simple ratios: as a ratio (3 : 1), as a fraction (¾), as a percentage (75%), or as a probability. All four say the same thing, and being able to move between them is examined directly. You should also be able to extract and interpret information from genetic crosses and family trees — in a family tree, work backwards from anyone showing a recessive phenotype, because you know their genotype for certain.
Family trees are read with two conventions and one deduction. The conventions: squares are male, circles female, and a shaded shape means affected. The deduction: start from anyone affected whose parents are not.
A condition that skips a generation like that must be recessive, because a dominant allele shows itself whenever it is present — so an affected child would need an affected parent. Once you know it is recessive, every affected person is homozygous recessive, and both of their parents must carry a copy. That single step usually unlocks the rest of the tree.
Worked example
Using the family tree above: is the allele causing the condition dominant or recessive, and what are the genotypes of the two parents? Use A for the dominant allele and a for the recessive one.
- Find anyone affected whose parents are not. Child 4 is affected; parents 1 and 2 are not.
- A dominant allele is expressed whenever it is present, so an affected child would have to have an affected parent. Neither parent is affected, so the allele cannot be dominant.
- Therefore it is recessive, and child 4 must be aa — two copies.
- Child 4 inherited one allele from each parent, so each parent must carry at least one a. Neither is affected, so neither can be aa.
Answer: The allele is recessive. Both parents are Aa — heterozygous carriers, unaffected themselves but each passing on one copy.
Common mistake
A 3 : 1 ratio is what you expect, not what you will get. Four offspring from that cross could easily be all brown — probability describes the chance for each one independently, not a guarantee about a small litter.
3.15Sex determination
Ordinary human body cells contain 23 pairs of chromosomes. Twenty-two pairs control characteristics only, but one pair carries the genes that determine sex.
• In females the sex chromosomes are the same: XX. • In males they are different: XY.
Worked example
Carry out a genetic cross to show sex inheritance, and give the ratio of male to female offspring.
- The mother is XX, so every egg carries an X.
- The father is XY, so half the sperm carry X and half carry Y.
- Punnett square: XX, XX from the X sperm; XY, XY from the Y sperm.
- Count: two XX and two XY.
Answer: A 1 : 1 ratio — a 50% chance of a male and 50% of a female for each child, because it depends entirely on whether the sperm carried an X or a Y.
Common mistake
The father determines the sex, not the mother — every egg carries an X, so it is the sperm that decides. And a 1 : 1 ratio does not mean a family of four will have two of each.
- Sex chromosomes
- the one pair of chromosomes out of 23 that determines sex: XX in females and XY in males
3.14Inherited disorders
Some disorders are inherited, caused by the inheritance of certain alleles. Two are named:
• Polydactyly — having extra fingers or toes — is caused by a dominant allele. • Cystic fibrosis — a disorder of cell membranes — is caused by a recessive allele.
The difference matters for the genetics. Polydactyly appears if a child inherits just one copy, so an affected child usually has an affected parent. Cystic fibrosis needs two copies, so two unaffected carriers can have an affected child — which is what makes it hard to predict.
Embryo screening tests embryos for these alleles, and you should be able to make informed judgements about the economic, social and ethical issues when you are given information.
In favour: it can prevent a child being born with a painful, life-shortening disorder; it reduces the lifelong cost of treatment and care; and parents who know they are carriers can have a child without that fear.
Against: screening implies that a life with a disorder is worth less, which many disabled people reject; it involves discarding embryos, which some people object to; it is expensive; and there is a concern about where the line is drawn once selection becomes possible at all.
Gene therapy raises the same tension — it may alleviate suffering, and it raises the same ethical questions. A good answer gives both sides and then reaches a judgement.
- Dominant allele
- an allele that is expressed whenever it is present, so only one copy is needed — polydactyly is caused by a dominant allele
- Recessive allele
- an allele expressed only when two copies are present — cystic fibrosis is caused by a recessive allele
- Allele
- one of the different forms a gene can take
3.17B–3.18BCodominance and sex-linked inheritance
Biology only — not on the Combined Science specification
Most inherited characteristics you meet are controlled by two alleles, one dominant and one recessive. Blood group is controlled by three, and two of them are codominant — when both are present, both are expressed, and neither masks the other.
The three alleles are usually written as A, B and O. A and B are codominant with each other, and both are dominant over O. Because a person still inherits only two alleles, one from each parent, six genotypes are possible and they give four blood groups.
Sex-linked inheritance is different again. Some genes sit on the X chromosome and have no counterpart on the much smaller Y chromosome. A female has two X chromosomes, so she carries two copies of every gene on the X. A male has one X and one Y, so he carries only one copy — and whatever allele that single copy holds is expressed, dominant or not.
That is why sex-linked disorders such as haemophilia and red–green colour blindness are far more common in males. A female with one faulty allele and one normal one is a carrier: she does not have the condition, because her second X chromosome carries a working copy, but she can pass the faulty allele to a son who will.
Worked example
A woman who is a carrier of red–green colour blindness has children with a man who has normal colour vision. What proportion of their sons are expected to be colour blind?
- The mother has two X chromosomes: one carries the normal allele, one carries the faulty allele.
- The father has one X, which carries the normal allele, and a Y.
- A son gets his Y from his father, so his single X must come from his mother.
- Half of the mother's X chromosomes carry the faulty allele, and a son has no second X to mask it.
Answer: Half of the sons are expected to be colour blind. None of the daughters will be, because each inherits a normal allele on the X from her father, but half of them will be carriers.
Common mistake
In a sex-linked cross the alleles must be drawn on the chromosomes, not on their own. Writing the father as carrying one normal allele and one faulty allele loses the whole point — his Y chromosome carries no allele for the gene at all.
Before you practise
- Learn the vocabulary precisely: gene, allele, dominant, recessive, homozygous, heterozygous, genotype, phenotype, gamete, zygote.
- A dominant allele shows with one copy; a recessive allele needs two.
- Set a Punnett square out fully — parents' genotypes, gametes, then the four boxes — and read the ratio off it.
- Sex is determined by the father's gamete: XX is female, XY is male, and the expected ratio is 1 : 1.
- In the ABO blood groups, A and B are codominant and both are dominant over O.
- Sex-linked disorders are more common in males because a male has only one X chromosome, so a recessive allele on it is expressed.
- Give probabilities in the form the question asks for — a ratio, a percentage or a fraction — and remember each birth is independent.